Obsessive compulsive disorder is a personality disorder that affects 1% of the US population, and is categorized by both obsessive thoughts and compulsive behaviors. The most prevalent compulsive behavior is checking, which is an attempt to mitigate anxiety about a situation assumed to be harmful if not addressed. Many studies have found a negative correlation between checking and metamemory (memory confidence, vividness and detail), however, there has been limited research on the effects of doubt, one of the main causes of checking behaviors, on metamemory. The current study used an online stove checking task first used by van den Haut and Kindt (2003) to investigate the influence of doubt on memory accuracy and metamemory in checking versus no checking groups as well as comparing people who are high versus low in OCD symptomatology. Doubt was not shown to have any effect on metamemory. However, when comparing the low and high OCD groups, significant results were found for both accuracy and memory confidence. Checking had an effect on memory accuracy, but only for the high OCD symptomatology group. The high OCD group also had overall higher confidence levels. Some of these results contradict previous findings.